Wednesday, May 20, 2015

What is "Showing not Telling"

By Leslie Colin Tribble

When the GROG had its first anniversary, we queried readers and asked what topics they’d like to see featured in the blog. We got many great responses and will be working through the list as the year progresses.

Today I’m covering some information about that perennial writers’ nemesis, Showing not Telling.

So what is Showing not Telling? Often writers hear from critique partners or agent/editors, “Show me, don’t tell me!”  What exactly does that mean? Let me show you.

I recently checked out E.B. White’s Trumpet of the Swan from our local library. Here are some ways E. B. White shows us information instead of telling us.

Instead of telling the reader, “Sam was happy,” E. B. White says, 

“His heart thumped from excitement and joy.” 

Which sentence is more interesting? Which sentence better transports the reader into Sam’s life? That’s what ‘showing’ does. It gives the reader a richer experience, one with depth and substance that draws them into the story and keeps them there.

Here are more examples. The author could have said, “The swans trumpeted loudly.”

Instead he paints us a picture,

“Every wild creature within a mile and a half of the pond heard the trumpeting of the swans.”


 When the female begins building her nest, E. B. White penned, 

“The female reached for grasses, for moss, for twigs – anything that was handy. Slowly, carefully she built up the nest until she was sitting on a big grassy mound.”

I also reached for another classic, Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Little House on the Prairie. In Chapter 16, Fire in the Chimney, the author never once tells us it’s autumn. Instead she uses words to give us clues and pictures for our minds, 

“The prairie had changed. Now it was a dark yellow, almost brown, and red streaks of sumac lay across it.”

“The wind was cooler now, and all along the creek bottoms flocks of wild ducks were rising, flying and settling again.”

“The tree-tops along the creek were colored now. Oaks were reds and yellows and browns and
greens. Cottonwoods and sycamores and walnuts were sunshiny yellow.” 

What a lovely way to inform the reader of the change of the seasons.

I know. All you picture book authors out there are thinking, “That’s all well and good for middle-grade books. But words are high-priced real estate in the realm of picture books. Wouldn’t it be better to be succinct and just tell the reader what’s happening? 

Not necessarily. Granted, you can’t wax quite as lyrical with picture books, but you can still provide the same depth by showing the reader what’s going on. 

Peter McCarthy’s latest book, First Snow does just that. Instead of writing, “The children were excited to go outside and play in the snow,” Peter writes, 

“Put on your boots! Put on your coat! Put on your hat and mittens! We are going outside!” 

The excitement coupled with his incredibly beguiling drawings of the animal children made me want to go with them. Then when Pedro falls off his sled, we are treated to this description, 

“Over a bump and into the air, Pedro flew! Thump! Bump! Fump! he went, into the snowbank at the bottom of the hill. 

I probably would have written, “Pedro sailed off his sled and landed in the snowbank.” Fewer words yes, but less life as well.

Here are some practice sentences for you to change from telling to showing. How will you transform these boring sentences into something the reader actually wants to read? Post your ideas in the comments so we can applaud your efforts. Also, search the Web for classroom lessons on Showing not Telling. If it works to make kids better writers, it'll work for you.

1.       Susan was excited to start school.

2.       The family went to buy a puppy.

3.       John was scared to jump off the diving board.

4.       The tall tree stood in the field.


Think about how you can bring these sentences to life using words that beckon to the reader and draw them into the story, living and breathing the plot, the characters, the surroundings. Play with the words in your stories. Weave those strands into a richness that makes your reader want to experience the story again and again and again. 

24 comments:

  1. Great post, Leslie. I love that line--words are high-priced real estate in picture books ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Tina, I probably read it somewhere else and appropriated it. :)

      Delete
  2. Leslie, yay - a craft post! Showing vs. Telling is always a good exercise and great way to revise to make writing more exciting. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Kathy - it's so much easier said than done!

      Delete
  3. great post. You really show us the way to "show". Good examples, too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You showed us how to "do as you do" in this post. Getting it right is a challenge, but such a Eureka! when you craft just the right words. That's a writer's high. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Pat it's definitely a "eureka!" feeling when it does come together. And sometimes you just know you've hit it right. Thanks for reading.

      Delete
  5. Leslie, you did a fine job with that post. I may try one of those sentences later.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading Sherri. It's so much easier to write about than do! :)

      Delete
  6. A perfect tutorial on showing vs telling. Well Done!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kind words, thanks! It was a fun post to write.

      Delete
  7. Replies
    1. Thanks for reading and commenting Jane!

      Delete
  8. Here I go. I choose sentence number one and four to show versus tell:
    1. Backpack packed with colorful folders and sharpened new pencils, a brand new outfit and matching shoes, Susan was ready for the first day of school.
    4. Out on the Illinois prairie where a harvest moon shines brightly, beneath the autumn moonlit sky, grows a majestic tree.
    Excellent, super, good job, great, Leslie.
    ~Suzy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh Suzy, I love your efforts on the exercise question! Majestic is such a great, underused word. Perfect!

      Delete
  9. Thank you, Leslie, for the examples and ways to show, not tell. Every word is judged.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right Charlotte about every word being judged. Excellent point. It's just so hard sometimes to see the "telling" in your own writing. Thanks for reading.

      Delete
  10. Inhale the words of E.B. White.
    Dwell in the "sunshiny yellow" of the Prairie.
    Crane your neck to see a tree as tall as too telephone poles and just as skinny.
    Appreciate LCT with your smile so big she can see it herself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Beautiful Jan! Thanks for reading!

      Delete
    2. Your thoughtful comment is making my day, Leslie.

      Delete
  11. Great post! It's nice to be reminded of this simple idea, yet complex to execute writing craft. Thanks for the practice sentences - and the challenge to use it in PBs.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Also, true to life in large part. Most often, the rallying cry was, "Get your boots! Get your boots on!" It was not, "It snowed last night."

    Great post and site. Looking forward to digging in.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great topic and well-written. The examples are great. What they show is how to replace telling words (abstract ideas) with physicality and sensory data. We experience the world through our bodies. When we are presented a world in terms of movement and senses, we experience what the characters are experiencing and feel the emotions as a result. We don't cry just because the author says the character is crying; we cry because we experience the character's pain.

    ReplyDelete